Welcome to St Paul Tavern
Nestled in the heart of St. Paul, Indiana, St. Paul Tavern is a delightful hidden gem renowned for its warm atmosphere and exceptional food. This cozy tavern shines with signature dishes like their legendary fried frog legs and crispy wings, impressing patrons with both flavor and value, such as their unbeatable all-you-can-eat deals. The friendly service enhances the inviting ambiance, making every visit memorable. With a diverse menu ranging from pizzas to hearty burgers, St. Paul Tavern is perfect for families, campers, and food enthusiasts alike. Experience the essence of community and comfort food at this beloved local favorite.
-
103 N Webster St, St Paul, IN 47272, United States Hotline: +1 765-525-9502
Welcome to the charming world of St Paul Tavern, a hidden gem tucked away in the heart of St Paul, Indiana. This establishment, located at 103 N Webster St, St Paul, IN 47272, invites you to experience a neighborhood tavern that radiates warmth and community spirit. With a phone call at +1 765-525-9502, you can reserve your spot to indulge in a delightful array of comfort foods that blend exceptional quality with a welcoming atmosphere.
St Paul Tavern has earned a loyal following, as echoed by patrons like Autumn Martin and Capri Williams, who applaud its boneless wings and cheesesticks, among other delights. The rave reviews underscore a consistent pattern: great food paired with excellent service, creating a perfect dining experience. This is not merely a restaurant; it is a place where locals gather, making memories over shared plates.
Among the culinary highlights, the tavern is notably known for its legendary fried frog legs, a dish surprising in its leanness and flavor profile. Customers repeatedly express their delight, making it a must-try for anyone visiting. Whether you're enjoying an all-you-can-eat fish special or a juicy burger, the quality remains high and the pricing refreshingly reasonable. The recent all-you-can-eat deal for just $15.99 stands as one of the best bargains in the region, promising an abundance of delicious choices.
The atmosphere at St Paul Tavern contributes immensely to its charm. As described by Phil Pettigrew, it perfectly encapsulates an authentic small-town experience; the ambiance feels warm and inviting. The extensive selection of bottled and canned beers, pointed out by Rob Streeter, complements the vibrant environment, making it an ideal spot for relaxation after a busy day, especially for visitors of the nearby Hidden Paradise campground.
In addition to the inviting ambiance, the menu showcases a variety of options that cater to all cravings—from crispy wings to delicious pizzas and fried pickles. With each dish prepared with care, diners feel the passion and commitment of the kitchen staff to provide not just meals, but an experience worth relishing again and again.
If you find yourself in the vicinity, make time to visit St Paul Tavern. It's where exceptional food, friendly faces, and community spirit converge in beautiful harmony. Don’t miss out on what promises to be a memorable culinary adventure. Your taste buds will thank you!
Came here to check out thier boneless wings and was really impressed. Cheesesticks were Good. Service was great. Was a great first impression. Will be back to try so.e of thier other food.
We have never had a bad experience. We love this place. The food is great atmosphere is wonderful and the service is excellent.
This is one of the best known secrets in Indiana. Fantastic food, great prices, and the servers are extremely friendly. Why go to a big chain restaurant when you can get great food at an out of the way gem.
Cool atmosphere, lots of bottle/can beer options. Pizza was good and wings were nice, crispy, and (temp) hot though the medium sauce was broken so it didn't coat well - still tasty. Sampler platter was great. Fantastic option for campers at Hidden Paradise campground. We'll be back!
If you're looking for an authentic small-town experience with unbeatable food, St. Paul Tavern is the place to be. Known for its legendary fried frog legs, this spot delivers a dish that’s surprisingly lean, flavorful, and downright delicious. From the moment you walk in, you’re embraced by the warm, hometown charm that defines this establishment. The sense of community and town loyalty is palpable, making it a welcoming stop for locals and visitors alike. One of the standout features of St. Paul Tavern is its incredible value. In 2025, finding an all-you-can-eat deal for just 15.99 is nearly unheard of, making it possibly the best bargain in the entire state. Whether you're here for a casual meal or a night out with friends, this tavern serves as a fantastic watering hole that perfectly captures the spirit of St. Paul. If you’re passing through or looking for a unique dining experience, don’t miss out on this hidden gem. St. Paul Tavern is a true treasure where great food, friendly faces, and unbeatable deals come together in the best way possible.
It's worth the effort to make it out here. I had the "all you can eat fish" while my wife got a really good burger. Both were hot and came with really good fries.
For a small town tavern, the food was pretty good and the atmosphere was enjoyable
Had a supreme pizza, breaded tenderloin, fried pickles, onion rings waffle fries delivered to the table. All in all pretty good